The Hidden Variable in AI Prompting: You

Most conversations about AI begin with the same question: “What prompt should I use?”

People look for templates, magic formulas, and shortcuts. But the truth is simpler and more surprising:

The most important factor in prompting is you.

Your clarity. Your thought process. Your ability to articulate what you want. Your discipline in iterating. Your skill in breaking down complex tasks.

This article explains why prompting style and prompting effort matter far more than any script and why organizations should focus on developing people, not just tools.

Every AI system is shaped by three forces:

  1. The clarity of the task
  2. The context provided
  3. The prompting style and effort of the human prompter

Two people can use the exact same prompt and generate completely different results because prompting is not about the words alone; it is driven by the human thinking behind them. Prompting style reflects how you approach a problem, how you frame your instructions, how clearly you express what you want, and how you guide the model through each step of the task. The same template in different hands produces different outcomes because prompting is fundamentally shaped by the person using it.

Effort matters just as much. Prompting is not a one-step request. It is an iterative, layered process. You refine, clarify, redirect, challenge, and co-create with the model. Asking for a strategic plan, a proposal, or an analysis in a single step often produces generic output. Thoughtful prompting requires multiple rounds of sharpening. It is a craft shaped by patience and intentionality.

This is where many teams misunderstand AI. They assume AI output is automated. They think prompts are interchangeable. They believe that skills live only in the model, not in the human. In reality, prompting sits on a ladder of effort. Low effort tasks such as extracting bullet points can be done with simple instructions. High effort tasks such as strategy, synthesis, and evaluation require structured prompting and multiple rounds of iteration.

Teams that do not understand this often think AI is failing them when in fact they have not provided the cognitive fuel the model needs. They mistake task complexity for model weakness. They expect expertise without offering the prompts that elicit it.

To use AI well, organizations need to develop both prompting style and prompting effort as core skills. This means cultivating people who:

  • think clearly and ask strong questions
  • know how to break down complex tasks
  • are willing to iterate rather than accept the first output
  • can provide the right context at the right time
  • understand the difference between low effort and high effort prompting
  • recognize that AI is not replacing thinking, it is amplifying it

When teams internalize this, AI becomes what it was always meant to be: a partner in problem-solving rather than an automatic answer machine.

The best prompt is not a template. It is a way of thinking — a mindset that combines clarity, curiosity, patience, and rigor. It is the human skill behind the prompt, not the prompt itself, that separates mediocre AI work from exceptional results.

If organizations want to harness AI effectively, they must develop their people, not just their tools. The future belongs to teams that understand the power of prompting style and the discipline of prompt effort.

Closing Reflection

I approach AI through the lens of hybrid intelligence, where humans and technology co-create outcomes. In this model, the human mind remains the core of the system. Prompting becomes an intellectual practice: one that requires curiosity, precision, and the willingness to think deeply. As a scholar–practitioner, I believe our greatest opportunity is not in automating human thought, but in elevating it. When we strengthen the human side of the equation, AI becomes a catalyst for insight, not a substitute for it.

 

Read Rehva’s Original Post on Linkedin »

PMCS STAFF

Rehva Jones

Chief Operating Officer at PMCS

Rehva Jones serves as the Chief Operating Officer for Professional Management Consulting Services (PMCS). She is a distinguished business leader, catalytic strategist, and expert problem-solver with over 20 years of experience in operations and... Read more
Featured Articles
Recent Posts
Categories

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Receive regular industry updates to help your business thrive.